What to Do If You Are Charged or Investigated for Fraud

Being caught up in a fraud investigation can be overwhelming, especially when you believe you’ve done nothing wrong.

With agencies like the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), Serious Fraud Office (SFO), Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), City of London Police, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC), and Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) increasingly focused on tackling serious white-collar crime, it’s not uncommon for individuals or businesses to find themselves under scrutiny — sometimes as witnesses, sometimes as suspects, and sometimes due to honest mistakes or misunderstandings.

Whatever the circumstances, fraud investigations are complex and can carry serious consequences. Early legal advice is essential to protect your rights and navigate the process with clarity and confidence.

In this article, Business Crime Senior Consultant Neena Jhawer explains what to expect and what steps to take if you’re facing an investigation or charges.

Obtaining early investigative advice  

It is really important that you allow your solicitor to deal with matters such as interviews under caution, requests for documentation from you or your company, and providing evidence in response to allegations that are made.  

Understanding what you are being charged of 

In England, Wales, and Northern Ireland, the Fraud Act 2006 defines various fraud offences, including fraud by false representation, failing to disclose information, and abuse of position. Penalties can be severe, including imprisonment and substantial fines.  

These offences can be heard in the Magistrates Court or the Crown Court. They carry a maximum sentence of 10 years. 

If you are being charged with or investigated for fraud in the UK, it’s crucial to understand your legal rights and take immediate, informed steps to protect yourself. 

What you can expect with Setfords

More time, more attention: With no targets, Setfords lawyers can dedicate more time to you.

Ultimate flexibility: Our lawyers can tailor their schedules to meet your needs.

Nationwide coverage: with hundreds of consultant lawyers across the UK, we’ll connect you with the right expert.

Dedicated specialist legal partner: work directly with your chosen lawyer from start to finish.

Highly experienced: Setfords lawyers have an average of 20 years’ experience, so you can be assured you’re in safe hands.

Capacity-based allocation: our lawyers never take on more work than they can handle, so you get the focus and attention you deserve.

Find out more

What are the agencies looking to prove?

False Representation 

False representation can be measured in various ways, including:

• Misleading Statements: False or misleading statements made to induce others to act in a way that results in harm or loss. 
• Omissions: Failing to disclose important information that could impact a decision (e.g. not disclosing risks, conflicts of interest, or relevant facts). 
• Falsified Documents: Fake records, altered financial statements, forged signatures, or fraudulent documents. 

Intent to Deceive 

Fraud usually requires intent. Agencies will look for evidence that shows the perpetrator knowingly misrepresented facts to deceive or mislead others for financial gain or to avoid legal responsibility. 

Financial Transactions 

Agencies will look at financial transactions for evidence, including:

• Unusual Patterns: Irregular or suspicious transactions, such as large sums of money being moved in a way that doesn’t make sense, or transactions with no clear business purpose. 
• Money Laundering Activities: In fraud cases, the movement of funds to hide their origin can indicate fraud. This may include transferring money to accounts in jurisdictions with weak regulations. 

Motive and Financial Gain 

Evidence showing that the defendant had a financial motive, such as obtaining money or property, is critical. This can be through direct financial benefit or by preventing losses. 

Victims’ Impact 

The agencies will look for a pattern of how the fraud caused harm to victims, such as financial loss, damage to credit, or harm to businesses or organisations. 

Witness Statements 

They will gather statements from witnesses, including whistleblowers or insiders. These can be critical in proving fraud. 

Electronic Evidence 

Agencies will look for electronic evidence in various forms, including:

• Digital trails (emails, text messages, chats, files) that provide evidence of fraudulent intent or actions.
• Metadata or logs from financial systems or databases that show irregular activity.

Fraudulent Schemes or Methods 

Patterns of fraudulent behaviour like Ponzi schemes, insider trading, misappropriation of funds, identity theft, and others can indicate fraud. 

Expert Analysis 

In cases involving complex financial transactions, forensic accountants or other experts are often used to analyse financial records and detect inconsistencies or fraudulent activity. 

Ultimately, each type of fraud requires specific evidence tailored to the scheme being investigated, and the enforcement agency will gather a combination of documents, witness statements, financial analysis, and other investigative techniques to prove fraud. 

What to do if you’re investigated for fraud

Seek Expert Legal Representation 

Engaging a solicitor with expertise in fraud cases is essential. Specialist fraud defence lawyers can guide you through the complexities of the legal system, advise you on the best course of action, and represent your interests effectively.  

Cooperate with Investigations

While it’s important to cooperate with authorities, remember that you have the right to remain silent and not self-incriminate. Anything you say can be used against you, so it’s advisable to consult with your solicitor before making any statements. 

Understand Your Rights 

You have the right to legal representation during interviews and the right to remain silent. Be cautious of waiving these rights without fully understanding the consequences. 

Prepare for Trial 

If the case proceeds to trial, your legal team will help prepare your defence, which may involve challenging the evidence, presenting alternative explanations, or negotiating plea deals if appropriate. 

Facing fraud charges or investigation is a serious matter that requires prompt and informed action. Engaging experienced legal professionals and understanding your rights are critical steps in navigating the legal process.